Winemaker's Notes
Somehow, the Zinfandel seemed to enjoy both the moderate growing season, as well as the hot, dry spell right at harvest (usually not considered to be a good thing). What excites me about this vintage of Zinfandel is that it has both the generosity of a relatively ‘big’ Zinfandel, while maintaining enough restraint (from alcohol and ‘cooked’ jamminess) and core structure (acidity and ‘good’ tannins) to age well and compliment food. It shows red, black and blue fruit aromas, peppercorns, along with a mild earthiness, kind of like comfort food for the nose. While it is built for a longer haul, the tannins melt quite readily at this early stage with a bit of food.
In my opinion, it is possible to have too much of a good thing. On a recent sales trip, someone told me that our Zins were not ‘big’ enough for their clientele who are accustomed to something akin to dry Port. My offhand response was, “when you are ready to be seduced rather than raped, give us a call.” Of course, I had a Groucho Marx delivery in mind rather than Mae West. But either way, it works. (Groucho would have been talking about wine, but one of his brothers would have probably been talking to Mae.)
Judi Scherrer –
The Wine Advocate – December 2008
The 2004 Zinfandel Scherrer Vineyard offers oodles of briery, cherry fruit intermixed with underbrush, pepper, and spice box characteristics. It is a richly fruity, deep, full-bodied Zinfandel to enjoy over the next 2–3 years. Fred Scherrer continues to turn out reasonably priced, consistently well made reds and whites. 90 points. Robert Parker
Judi Scherrer –
Stephen Tanzer’s International Wine Cellar – May 2009
Inky ruby. Cassis, mulberry and licorice aromas give way to brighter red berries and flowers with air. Sappy raspberry,cherry and plum flavors are velvety in texture and seem devoid of tannins. Very rich, almost creamy Zinfandel with excellent cling and sweetness. A late jolt of minerals adds energy to the finish. For such a rich wine, this is surprisingly light on its feet. 90 points. Josh Raynolds